Archived News Item
Gospel reflection for 16th Sunday in Ordinary Time, Year CJuly 19, 2007
Sister Veronica Lawson rsm (
The story of Martha and Mary has been interpreted fairly consistently over the centuries. Mary’s silent contemplative pose at the feet of Jesus is generally affirmed while Martha’s action-oriented focus is seen as a less desirable Christian stance. To be a ‘Mary’ is to ‘choose the better part’. To be a ‘Martha’ is to be ‘anxious and distracted about many things’.
In recent times, some interpreters have re-evaluated this reading of the Martha-Mary story. They have drawn attention to the many voices that inform the gospels and have suggested that this particular text reflects a struggle in some of the early Church communities over the role of women in leadership and ministry. One voice in the text comes from those who want to downplay the initiative of women like Martha and to affirm the silence of women like Mary. The same voice seems to pit the two women over against each other and to cast Jesus in the role of arbiter between them, approving Mary’s choice over against Martha’s. This voice has had the effect of creating a false dichotomy and of reducing the women to exemplars of active ministry on the one hand and of quiet contemplation on the other. In other words, the judgment of Luke’s Jesus reflects the views of a certain group in Luke’s house churches rather than the words of Jesus of Nazareth.
A more women-friendly voice in the text presents Martha as the householder who welcomes or receives Jesus into her household church. This is possibly the voice of a circle of women disciples who preserved memories of women like Martha and Mary in less divisive ways. For these women, Martha is a generous host who uses her resources for the sake of the community. She welcomes those who share faith in Jesus, among them her sister Mary. The designation ‘sister’ does not necessarily denote blood relationship. Mary may be one among many sisters and brothers in faith who gather to hear the teaching of Jesus. According to the narrator, Martha is ‘pulled in every direction’ (periespato) by many ministerial tasks (peri pollen diakonian), and most leaders can sympathise with her in this. There is no indication in this description that she is distracted. This is in contrast with the subsequent evaluation of the Lukan Jesus. Coming from the lips of Jesus, words like ‘distracted’ or ‘anxious and troubled by many things’ service a negative interpretation of Martha’s leadership.
This story is problematic in many ways. It forms part of a broader Lukan canvas where women provide the model for leadership but are more often than not excluded from its exercise. This is in contrast with the ways that women are presented elsewhere in the gospels, especially in John.